As a Canadian visiting, seemed like the "owner(?)" was just a little rude, cause she was on the phone while we were cashing out and asking some questions - Sort of treated me as a person that didn't know anything. Aside from that, this place is one of those over hyped shops in my opinion, as 2 packs of small brownie baking mix will run you 20 bucks, while a bag of brownies would run you around 13 bucks. Steep. But regardless, the brownies are pretty good. I would give 3.5 if I could.
Go after 5.30pm for $1.50 unwrapped brownies. Best value and the selection changes every day. Delicious sticky chewy brownies packed full of flavour.
Was really looking forward to trying Fat Witch whilst in NYC, I bought the double chocolate witch and was very disappointed. The brownie did not have a fudgy texture and it didn’t have a rich dense chocolate taste. The texture is dry, like a chocolate cake, not a brownie. Not worth $3 unfortunately!
I love this place and love their brownies. Every time I am in Chelsea I stop by and get one. Today I was walking down the street and I sneezed and when my head jerked down on account of the sneeze I saw a sticker on the sidewalk with their logo on it. It's a good logo and also I'm impressed that they were able to advertise to me mid-sneeze, across town. That was the impetus for me leaving this review.
Lovely little place with nice brownies! I prefer more crispy brownie but this one is nice nonetheless! :)
Fat Witch Bakery is a US Bakery based in Manhattan New York, New York. Fat Witch Bakery is located at 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA.
Please contact with Fat Witch Bakery using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Fat Witch Bakery opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Bakery in Manhattan New York